Should I Invest When the Stock Market Is at an All-Time High?

Updated: Oct 26
On a hundred years of evidence, no, a record is not a reason to wait. Since 1950 the S&P 500 has closed at an all-time high on roughly 7% of all trading days, according to J.P. Morgan Asset Management: one day in every fourteen. Records are not the exception in this system. They are the schedule.
Why does "all-time high" feel like a warning?
In August 2026 the S&P 500 closed at 7,798.99, a record. You heard it and felt a small clench. Too late. I missed it.
The fear comes from the wrong picture. We imagine a mountain: climb, reach the peak, and from a peak the only way is down. But an all-time high is not a mountain peak. It is an odometer turning. Underneath it something real keeps moving: earnings, productivity, the next company entering the list.

What did earlier "tops" turn into?
Five Septembers, index levels rounded:
September 1976: around 105. The year the first Apple computer was built.
September 1987: around 320. One month before Black Monday, the worst one-day crash in market history. It felt like the top.
September 2008: around 1,250. The month Lehman Brothers fell. The scariest September of modern finance.
September 2025: around 6,500. Twenty-one record closes already that year.
September 2026: around 7,800. A record set three weeks earlier.

September 1987 felt dangerously high; one month later the S&P 500 lost about 20% in a single day, per the Federal Reserve's account of the crash. Yet that terrifying 320 is a price today's investor would take with both hands. The Septembers that felt like tops turned out to be floors.
What do you own when you buy "the market"?
An index like the S&P 500 is a list: the five hundred largest listed companies in the United States, weighted by size. And the list cleans itself. A company that fails shrinks and drops off; a company that grows takes its place. Kodak leaves, Apple enters. The rule does the work.
A fund or ETF is simply a shared basket that buys all five hundred at once. You are buying the rule: whoever wins, I own a piece of it.
In the SPIVA scorecard from S&P Dow Jones Indices, roughly 9 out of 10 actively managed US large-cap funds failed to beat the S&P 500 over the 15 years to December 2024. Warren Buffett drew his conclusion in his 2016 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders: "When trillions of dollars are managed by Wall Streeters charging high fees, it will usually be the managers who reap outsized profits, not the clients. Both large and small investors should stick with low-cost index funds." Nine out of ten expensive professionals fail to beat the list they are paid to beat.

What has the market done over a hundred years?
The record starts in 1926. Since then, according to the CFA Institute Research Foundation, on Ibbotson data, $1 invested in US large-company stocks had grown to about $14,750 by the end of 2025, dividends reinvested: roughly 10% a year, in dollars. From 13 to 7,799. Every crisis is a dent. The direction is the century. Depression, world war, oil shocks, Black Monday, dot-com, 2008, a pandemic: the line fell hard every time, and every time the self-cleaning list refilled itself and ended higher.

How often is the market at an all-time high?

Almost a third of the record highs since 1950, per J.P. Morgan Asset Management, became floors the market never fell more than 5% below. Starting at a record has not been worse than starting on an ordinary Tuesday: J.P. Morgan's figures for 1988 to 2024 put the average one-year return after a new high at 13%, against 12% for any day.
Should I wait for a dip, or start now?
Crashes are real. The highs of 1929 and 2000 sat right before years of nothing, and nobody, including every professional I met inside a bank, can tell you in advance which high is which. Timing cannot solve that. Time can: a horizon of a decade or more, and a fixed amount invested automatically every month, so you buy at highs, at lows and on every boring day between. Time in the market beats timing the market. J.P. Morgan measured it: $10,000 in the S&P 500 from January 2005 to December 2024 became $71,750. Miss only the 10 best days of those 20 years: $32,871. Waiting for the dip is fear wearing a spreadsheet.

A note: this is education, not financial advice. I don't know your personal situation, so I can't advise you on it. Use these numbers as a starting point for your own thinking, and if you need advice for your own situation, talk to an independent, licensed financial adviser.
What did I do myself?
A confession. Two decades inside a bank did not make me immune to any of this. I used to try to time the market. Sell before the dip, buy back cheaper, beat the index with my own cleverness. It does not work. I have my receipts, and the nine out of ten professionals above have theirs. So I dropped the strategy, and something better arrived in its place: I do not want to look at my app constantly, and now I do not have to.
What should you do this month?
If you already invest monthly: confirm the standing order ran this month. If you do not: look up an index fund's chart over twenty years or more, find the moments that felt like "the top", and notice where they sit now. Then ask: what am I actually waiting for?
Frequently asked questions
Q. Is a record high a bad time to start investing? A. Not on the evidence. Records are the schedule: about 7% of trading days since 1950, and one-year returns after a new high averaged 13% against 12% for any day, per J.P. Morgan. Past averages guarantee nothing.
Q. Does "sell in May and go away" work? A. The rhyme says stay out until September; in August 2026 the S&P 500 set a record. A rhyme can be true about averages and still be terrible advice about your money.
Q. Should I invest my cash buffer at an all-time high? A. No. Three to six months of expenses stay in cash (How Much Cash Is Enough?). Only the money above that floor is in question, and in savings it loses to inflation (Is 3% on Savings a Good Return?).
About the author
Céline Pujdak is the Founder of Cello Wealth. She spent two decades inside one of Europe's largest banks, managing billions. Cello Wealth turns that experience into financial education for women who earn well but do not yet own enough.
Originally shared with Cello Notes readers on 6 September 2026. Get the Sunday letter: Cello Notes on Substack.
About Cello Wealth
Cello Notes is published by Cello Wealth, founded by Céline Pujdak. Cello Wealth helps women understand their money, build investment portfolios and take control of their long-term wealth.
Educational purposes only. Not financial advice. I don't know your personal situation and cannot advise on it. Market figures are stated as of August and September 2026, in US dollars, and are not updated. No fund, broker or bank is recommended. The value of investments can fall as well as rise; past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. For your personal situation, talk to an independent, licensed financial adviser.
Sources:



Comments